Paying for medical care under the takaful model

Paying for medical care under the takaful model

Islamic health insurance explained: tabarru fund, wakala, surplus and qard, IFSB and AAOIFI standards, and practical options in France, where none exists.

Islamic health insurance rests on a tabarru' fund fed by participants' contributions and run by a takaful operator paid through wakala, which reimburses medical costs without interest or speculation; in France, however, no takaful health product has been identified.

Why healthcare suits takaful mutual help

The IFSB defines takaful as pooling exposure to uncertain events so that participants help one another in line with sharia. Illness illustrates the mechanism well: everyone contributes, and the common fund pays the medical bills of whoever falls sick.

The participants' risk fund behind every reimbursement

Standard IFSB-14 identifies the participants' risk fund, or PRF, which pools underwriting risk. In health cover, this fund pays for hospital stays and consultations; the operator only manages it, earning a wakala fee whose rate is stated in the contract.

Pure risk and no maysir in medical claims

A takaful health contract covers pure risk only, meaning loss or no loss, with no prospect of gain. A health reimbursement is therefore capped at costs actually incurred, which answers the gambling, or maysir, objection raised against conventional insurance.

Gharar made tolerable by a donation contract

According to the takaful FAQ of State Life in Pakistan, conventional insurance is an exchange contract tainted by excessive gharar. Takaful health cover instead relies on tabarru', a gift to the common pool, where uncertainty about claims remains acceptable.

Where unused health contributions end up

When a year's reimbursements fall short of contributions, a surplus arises. It may be paid back to participants, lower next year's contributions or become a renewal discount; the detailed rules appear on the page about how takaful surplus is shared.

When medical spending exceeds the fund

An epidemic or rising hospital costs can push the fund into deficit. IFSB-14 then provides for qard, an interest-free loan from the shareholders' fund to the PRF, repayable only out of future surpluses, which spreads the shock over several financial years.

Malaysia's framework as a health benchmark

In Malaysia, takaful falls under the Islamic Financial Services Act 2013, with licences issued by Bank Negara Malaysia, and is open to everyone regardless of religion. BNM's 2018 draft framework requires participants' consent before any revision of the tabarru' rate.

France: no takaful top-up health plan found

In France, the ACPR supervises 660 insurance bodies and has taken no public position on takaful. Identified takaful offers cover life and funeral insurance; no compliant top-up health plan was found, hence the value of reviewing health mutuals marketed as Islamic.

Assessing a conventional health plan instead

A French top-up health plan falls under ordinary law, either the Insurance Code or the Mutual Insurance Code, and Solvency II. Some Muslims then look at how reserves are invested and surpluses returned, which does not make the contract takaful; consulting a scholar remains advisable.

Pilgrim health during Hajj and Umrah

The insurance bundled with a Hajj visa obtained through Nusuk, underwritten by Tawuniya, covers accidental death and repatriation but not treatment outside the Kingdom. The French ministry recommends hospital cover, as explained in takaful Hajj insurance.

Medical liability: a South African precedent

Health also concerns practitioners. In South Africa, Safire Insurance and Genoa Underwriting Managers launched a takaful medical and general liability policy on 10 November 2021, with contributions held in a separate bank account and approval from a sharia adviser.

Sharia screening of health fund investments

Reserves of a takaful health fund may not be invested in alcohol, tobacco, pornography or weapons. They go into sukuk, Islamic banks or compliant equities under the oversight of a sharia committee, which in Pakistan is subject to an annual audit.

How to take out takaful health cover

  1. Check with the local regulator, such as Bank Negara Malaysia or the SECP, that the operator holds a takaful licence rather than a mere halal label.
  2. Identify the model used, wakala or mudaraba, and ask for the signed opinion of the operator's sharia committee.
  3. Compare the contribution, the wakala fee percentage and the surplus-sharing formula written into the contract.
  4. Review reimbursement caps, waiting periods and the list of excluded treatments, particularly conditions that predate enrolment.
  5. Keep prescriptions and invoices, then submit each expense within the stated deadline so the risk fund can reimburse it.
  6. Check the yearly surplus or deficit statement every year, along with any tabarru' revision submitted for your approval.

What makes up the price of takaful health cover

ComponentRoleWhat drives it
Tabarru' (gift to the fund)Funds medical reimbursements for all participantsAge, declared health, chosen limits
Wakala feePays the operator for managing the fundPercentage set in the contract, specific to each operator
Mudaraba shareRewards the operator from investment profitsOnly under a mudaraba or hybrid model
Surplus returnedGives back the unused excessClaims experience for the year; operator share capped at 50% in Malaysia
DeductibleLeaves part of the costs to the insuredChosen plan; a higher deductible lowers the contribution

Documents requested when joining a health plan

Traps to avoid with takaful health cover

Your questions on Islamic health insurance

Is there a takaful top-up health plan in France?

None has been identified. Takaful products launched in France concern life insurance, with Swiss Life's Salam in 2013, and death and repatriation cover, with SAAFI's Sakina in 2020. For health, you therefore need to review conventional contracts or duly authorised foreign offers.

Do scholars accept the principle of takaful health cover?

AAOIFI approved its Sharia Standard No. 26 on Islamic insurance in 2006. Whether a specific contract is acceptable still depends on its structure; the opinion of the operator's sharia committee, published or available on request, is the reference to consult before signing.

Can a non-Muslim join a takaful health plan?

Yes, where the framework allows it. Malaysia's 2013 Islamic financial services law sets no faith requirement for members. The participant simply accepts the fund's rules: a gift to the common pool, compliant investments and possible surplus sharing.

What happens if the health fund runs a deficit?

The operator advances a qard, an interest-free loan, to the participants' risk fund. The loan is repaid only from surpluses in later years, so no refund reaches members until the debt has been cleared.

Can my health contributions rise during the contract?

In Malaysia, the draft operational framework published by Bank Negara Malaysia in May 2018 requires participants' consent for any tabarru' revision. Elsewhere, read the pricing review clause and ask who decides an increase: the operator alone or the participants.

Takaful operators and organisations

Prudential BSN TakafulMalaysian takaful operator, a joint venture of Prudential and Bank Simpanan Nasional, offering family and general takaful cover.Takaful EmaratUAE takaful operator specialising in health and family protection cover for individuals and businesses.Al Rajhi TakafulSaudi takaful operator offering Sharia-compliant motor, health, home and protection cover.CIBAFI – Conseil général des banques et institutions financières islamiquesInternational body representing Islamic financial institutions, including takaful players, and publishing research and policy positions.

Indicative list: assuranceislamique.com has no commercial link with these organisations. Always check the licence with the local regulator.

Related pages