The mudaraba model: participants provide capital, the operator manages it

The mudaraba model: participants provide capital, the operator manages it

Mudaraba in takaful insurance: the operator as mudarib, sharing of returns and surplus, differences from wakala, and the relevant IFSB and AAOIFI standards.

In the mudaraba model, participants supply the capital and the takaful operator invests it as manager in return for an agreed share of the profits, so the surplus may be split between shareholders and participants, unlike under a pure wakala arrangement.

A partnership of capital and labour

Mudaraba is a classic contract of Islamic commercial law: the rabb al-mal provides the money and the mudarib contributes expertise. Applied to takaful, it makes participants the capital providers and the operator a manager paid according to results.

Ownership of the funds according to the IFSB

IFSB-14, the risk management standard published in December 2013, names mudaraba alongside wakala. It states that, from a sharia perspective, participants under this model are regarded as the owners of the funds entrusted to the operator.

A profit-sharing ratio set in advance

The mudarib is not paid a fixed amount but a percentage of profits, agreed when the policy is taken out. If the investments earn nothing, the operator receives nothing on that basis, which in principle aligns its interests with those of participants.

Surplus shared with shareholders

According to State Life's takaful FAQ in Pakistan, the surplus is divided between shareholders and participants under mudaraba, whereas under wakala it goes wholly to participants. The allocation mechanism is set out in our analysis of the takaful surplus.

A recurring criticism of the model

Sharing the underwriting surplus with the operator is contested, because that surplus stems from the claims experience rather than from an investment. A hybrid model meets this objection by applying wakala to underwriting and mudaraba to investments only.

Permitted investments

The mudarib may invest only in sharia-compliant assets such as real estate, Islamic banks, screened equities and sukuk, according to State Life. Alcohol, tobacco, pornography and arms are excluded, as explained in how takaful funds are invested.

Investment risk in family takaful

IFSB-14 separates the participants' risk fund, or PRF, from the participants' investment fund, or PIF, which is specific to family products with a savings element. In the PIF, participants carry the investment risk, consistent with mudaraba logic.

When a mudaraba loses money

In a mudaraba, financial losses fall on the capital provider unless the manager was at fault or negligent, in which case the manager loses only its effort. For a takaful savings plan, the value of savings can therefore go down.

Regulation in Pakistan

The SECP's Takaful Rules 2005 permitted products based on wakala, on mudaraba or on both. The Takaful Rules 2012 replaced them and opened the way for conventional insurers to run takaful windows alongside their existing business.

The applicable AAOIFI standards

AAOIFI Sharia Standard No. 26, approved in 2006, governs Islamic insurance. On the accounting side, FAS 43, applicable since 1 January 2025, and FAS 42 on presentation require a description of the takaful structure and of the operator's role.

Governance of the mudarib

As manager of other people's money, the operator is subject to governance rules: IFSB-8 on takaful governance and IFSB-10 on sharia governance were adopted on 23 November 2009. Pakistan also requires an annual sharia audit of every operator.

What to compare before choosing

When assessing a mudaraba offer, a participant should compare the profit-sharing ratio, the portion of underwriting surplus left to shareholders and the track record of returns. A hybrid wakala-mudaraba model often shows both parameters separately in the documents.

Reviewing a mudaraba-based takaful offer

  1. Check the operator's licence with the regulator, for instance the SECP in Pakistan or Bank Negara Malaysia.
  2. Establish whether mudaraba applies only to investments, to the underwriting surplus, or to both at once.
  3. Note the profit-sharing ratio between participants and the mudarib operator as written in the contract.
  4. Request the investment policy and the list of sector exclusions approved by the sharia board.
  5. For a savings product, review the return history of the participants' investment fund.
  6. Keep the sharia board's fatwa and the operator's most recent sharia audit report.

What a mudaraba contract costs

ItemHow it is calculatedWhat makes it vary
Risk contributionAmount paid into the tabarru' fundAge, cover, risk profile
Mudarib's share of returnsPercentage of investment profitsContractual ratio, asset performance
Share of underwriting surplusSplit between shareholders and participantsClaims experience for the year, contract clause
Retakaful chargesContribution to the retakaful fundExposure to major losses
Investment lossesBorne by participantsMarkets, no fault by the manager

Documents required for a mudaraba contract

Frequent mistakes with mudaraba

Your questions on mudaraba takaful

Can the mudarib operator be paid if the fund loses money?

Not under the mudaraba itself: its share is calculated on profits actually made. With no profit, it receives nothing on investments. A hybrid contract can, however, add a fixed wakala fee, which remains payable regardless of results.

Why do some people prefer wakala to mudaraba?

Because under mudaraba the surplus from underwriting may be shared with shareholders, which some consider questionable. Wakala fixes the operator's pay in advance and leaves the surplus to participants, as State Life points out.

Is mudaraba recognised by standard-setting bodies?

Yes, the IFSB lists mudaraba among the operational models of takaful in its IFSB-14 standard. Each product must nevertheless be approved by the operator's sharia board, which should be consulted when in doubt.

Which products rely most on mudaraba?

It is most relevant to family takaful with a savings component, where the participants' investment fund carries the investment risk. In general takaful, it is used instead to reward the management of reserves.

Takaful operators and organisations

AAOIFI – Normes chariaStandard-setting body publishing the Sharia, accounting and governance standards used by many takaful operators.ICIEC – Groupe de la Banque islamique de développementSharia-compliant multilateral insurer covering export credit and investment in Islamic Development Bank member countries.IFSB - Islamic Financial Services BoardInternational standard-setting body based in Kuala Lumpur, issuing prudential standards for Islamic banking, capital markets and takaful.Abu Dhabi National TakafulAbu Dhabi takaful company providing Sharia-compliant health, motor, home and business cover.

Indicative list: assuranceislamique.com has no commercial link with these organisations. Always check the licence with the local regulator.

Related pages