Shipowners and shippers: takaful applied to the sea

Shipowners and shippers: takaful applied to the sea

Marine takaful: hull and machinery, shipowner liability, cargo, IFSB-18 retakaful and the sharia checks shipowners and shippers should carry out.

Islamic marine insurance applies takaful to ships, shipowners' liability and cargo on board. Given the sums at stake, it almost always relies on retakaful governed by the IFSB-18 principles and on sharia supervision of the operator.

The lines of marine insurance

The sector distinguishes hull and machinery cover, which protects the ship itself, the shipowner's liability towards third parties, crew and the environment, and insurance of cargo on board. A marine takaful offer can cover one or several of these lines.

Exposed values out of the ordinary

A single ship can be worth more than all the contributions to a small participants' fund. A marine takaful operator therefore keeps a small share of the risk and cedes the rest, or one sinking would threaten the whole fund's solvency.

Retakaful according to the IFSB

Published in April 2016, the IFSB-18 principles present retakaful as the Islamic alternative to reinsurance, for both life and non-life business. Operators contribute to a common fund governed by tabarru', ta'awun, the prohibition of riba and transparency.

The Gulf, a hub for retakaful

The January 2016 roundtable on the IFSB-18 draft was held in Manama, Bahrain, with Munich Re Retakaful, Hannover Re, Bank Negara Malaysia and the DFSA. Bahrain had already hosted the public hearing on Shari'ah Standard No. 26 in 2006.

P&I clubs and the mutual spirit

Shipowners' liability is traditionally covered by protection and indemnity clubs, organised as shipowner mutuals. This sharing among peers recalls ta'awun, but the difference between takaful and a mutual lies in how funds are invested and in sharia supervision.

General average seen as mutual help

When a master sacrifices part of the cargo to save the ship, the loss is shared among all the interests involved: this is general average. This age-old mechanism of maritime solidarity fits naturally into the risk-sharing logic of takaful.

What the sharia board checks

The sharia board reviews the policy, the management model and the investment policy. In Pakistan, the Takaful Rules 2005 required a Shariah Board of recognised scholars and an annual sharia audit; a shipowner can ask for these reports before entrusting its fleet.

Investing shipowners' contributions

Marine contributions, often large, may only be placed in compliant assets: property, Islamic banks, screened shares and sukuk. The rules on investing takaful funds exclude the alcohol, tobacco, pornography and weapons sectors.

Ships financed according to sharia

A ship acquired through ijara remains the property of the lessor, who requires hull and machinery cover for its value. Under murabaha, the financing institution usually asks for equivalent cover; choosing takaful then depends on the offer available and its sharia board's view.

The situation of European shipowners

No marine takaful operator has been identified in France, Belgium or Switzerland. The ACPR has taken no position on takaful, and in 2014 Solvency II was seen as the main obstacle to the development of takaful in Europe.

Surpluses and deficits of a marine fund

A year without a major loss can produce a surplus, returned to participants or offset against their future contributions. In a deficit, the operator can advance an interest-free qard, which the IFSB-14 standard allows to be repaid only from later surpluses.

Cargo carried on board

Goods loaded on board fall under a cover separate from that of the ship, explained in the article on takaful transport insurance. The shipper insures the value of its goods, while the shipowner covers its working asset and its liability.

Insuring a ship or cargo under takaful

  1. Define the lines to cover: hull and machinery, shipowner liability, cargo on board, or a combination.
  2. Find a licensed takaful operator with a marine line and enough retakaful capacity for the value of the ship.
  3. Ask who the retakaful partners are and what share of the risk is kept in the participants' fund.
  4. Obtain the sharia board's written opinion and the operator's latest sharia audit report.
  5. Compare contribution, wakala fee, excesses and the surplus-sharing rule under the chosen model.
  6. Plan a procedure for prompt reporting of losses at sea, with a master's protest, logbook and survey.

Price components of marine takaful cover

ComponentPurposeKey factors
Contribution to the fundFunds the claims retained by the operatorType, age and value of the ship, navigation areas
Retakaful costTransfers most of the risk to the retakaful fundInsured value, capacity of the retakaful market
Wakala feePays for the operator's managementRate set in the contract
ExcessAmount left to the shipowner per eventShipowner's policy, damage history
Surplus or qardPossible refund or repayment of a deficitAnnual result of the marine fund

Documents required for a marine policy

Pitfalls specific to marine takaful

Questions from shipowners and shippers

Does marine takaful exist outside Muslim-majority countries?

No marine takaful operator has been identified in French-speaking Europe. Established takaful frameworks are found notably in Malaysia and Pakistan, and retakaful players have met in Manama. A European shipowner should therefore review a conventional contract with a sharia adviser.

Why is conventional reinsurance a problem?

According to the IFSB-18 principles, retakaful shares risk among operators instead of transferring it to a reinsurer for a premium, and its funds respect the prohibition of riba. Occasional use of conventional reinsurance is for each operator's sharia board to assess.

Are shipowners' mutuals acceptable?

Their logic of sharing among peers comes close to ta'awun, but their investments are not screened according to sharia and they have no sharia board. The question is one for a qualified scholar or board, who should be shown the club's rules.

How does AAOIFI govern a marine operator's accounts?

The FAS 43 standard, in force since 1 January 2025, deals with accounting for takaful and for retakaful held by the participants' fund. The FAS 42 standard governs presentation and the disclosures to publish in the financial statements.

Takaful operators and organisations

Prudential BSN TakafulMalaysian takaful operator, a joint venture of Prudential and Bank Simpanan Nasional, offering family and general takaful cover.Takaful EmaratUAE takaful operator specialising in health and family protection cover for individuals and businesses.Al Rajhi TakafulSaudi takaful operator offering Sharia-compliant motor, health, home and protection cover.ICIEC – Groupe de la Banque islamique de développementSharia-compliant multilateral insurer covering export credit and investment in Islamic Development Bank member countries.

Indicative list: assuranceislamique.com has no commercial link with these organisations. Always check the licence with the local regulator.

Related pages